HOAs are so well known for their ridiculous rules that leave their neighbors broken and jaded that I’m surprised anyone lives in housing complexes or gated communities at all anymore. Still, story after story reaches the media telling the sad tales of people who didn’t read their handbook before moving in and signing their pact with the devil.
For 77 year-old US Army veteran Fred Quigley, the news from his HomeOwners Association that his American flag (or more accurately, his pole) is “against regulation” looks like it’s going to end in a court case. What could be more American? Apparently, being less than 20 miles from the shores of Lake Erie and so close to the border, the HOA seems to have let the Canadian seep in and have completely forgotten the rules of their state and country.
Other HOAs have wised up to the local laws and completely deny telling their home owners to take down their American flags, preferring to keep their illegal high-pressure tactics under wraps. Ah, they are starting to smarten up…. is it time to be afraid of the big bad HOAs? Hmm, let’s see. What other kinds of crazy rules have these community dictators come up with?
How about telling a disabled man that he doesn’t need a handicapped parking spot for his wheelchair accessible van or telling an entire neighborhood and the Homes for Our Troops organization that they can’t build a pre-approved new house for an injured vet… because their plans are too small - not jaded enough for you? Alright then, let’s continue with the HOA disasters, shall we?
Can you imagine facing jail time and foreclosure for planting too many roses? Or not enough grass? These particular rules are a little bit lame, but not quite so jaded that they are completely lacking any kind of human emotion just yet. To that end, how about the story of a man who lost his entire family when a plane fell from the sky and destroyed his home. His HOA, unfazed by the fact that the man couldn’t stand the thought of rebuilding his home exactly as it was and being constantly reminded of what he lost, sent notice via legal counsel to let the man know that his shingles didn’t match the other houses in the neighborhood, flat out refusing to have any kind of discussion with the man in person. Compassionate, huh?
Still feeling safe in your assumption that your HOA’s rules still won’t really affect you, baring major accidents or gardening mishaps? You’re in luck! Courts have recently upheld an HOAs right to control your actions not just in your yard, but in the privacy of your own bathroom, banning cigarette smoking in the shower and on the toilet (and your balcony, and your patio, and your courtyard, and the poolside….)! After all, people want their open spaces to be safe and clean for kids to play, right? Oh wait, no. Wrong. It seems that HOAs are also completely jaded about children. In central Florida, the Edgewater HOA recently proposed rule changes to ban children from play outside, including toying with Big Wheels, skateboards and playing tag. The proposal suggests that parents could be fined $100 for every violation. According to one jaded HOA board member, Kim Scott:
They came in and rented in a community that does not have a playground and is not conducive to children. Then they expect the children to play in the driveways and parking lot. You wouldn’t see them playing in the parking lot at Walmart or Kmart, but they come here and turn the children loose.
Note to prospective renters: if your HOA compares your house to a Walmart, maybe you should just walk away.